Radio ban causing debate after Nico Rosberg incident

  • Published on 11 Jul 2016 13:48
  • comments 2
  • By: Dominik Wilde

Formula One's radio ban has come more scrutiny after Nico Rosberg received a penalty for breaking radio rules at the British Grand Prix.

Rosberg received instructions relating to a gearbox issue, and was later hit with a 10 second time penalty after the FIA deemed the instructions to be against the rules.

Red Bull team principal Christian Horner, whose driver Max Verstappen moved up to second place as a result of Rosberg's penalty, insisted that Mercedes knew "all too well" that they were breaking the rules, but admitted that the rule needed working on.

"We need to address this issue at the next strategy group meeting and modify the rule," he said. "I understand what the FIA wanted to achieve with driver coaching, but in the case of technical problems, we must be able to support the drivers."

Mercedes motorsport boss Toto Wolff added: "These rules maybe need a rethink. It needs to be discussed."

Despite the penalty, Mercedes, who plan to appeal the decision, believe they did nothing wrong.

"It was a very critical problem," said Rosberg. "I was about to stop on track, so they told me 'change default' to try and fix it."

"I am sure that we interpreted the rules correctly," added team chairman Niki Lauda

A question of consistency?

The debate of whether Mercedes' radio messages were legal comes one week after Force India were not allowed to inform Sergio Perez of a critical brake problem, but Williams were allowed to warn Felipe Massa of a similar problem.

Force India team manager Andy Stevenson agrees, saying it was no different to Austria a week ago when Sergio Perez could not be told his brakes were failing.

"No one understands why they were (allowed to tell the driver) and we weren't," he said.

"How absurd is that?" Williams' Pat Symonds told Auto Motor und Sport. "How many tens of thousands of pounds did that accident cost the team?"

GB Silverstone - 10 July 2016

Replies (2)

Login to reply
  • RacetoWin

    Posts: 95

    A 10 second penalty for a call from the pits to "manually pass through 7th gear" seems to be a small price to pay vs a retirement.

    i believe more teams will now risk a penalty to keep the car from slowing off pace or retiring. force india could've saved both cars from brake failure at the redbull ring, 10 seconds for them to have 2 cars in the points is small price to pay.

    • + 0
    • Jul 11 2016 - 19:06
    • ianf1

      Posts: 185

      It's not just the points, they would have saved the money from not having all that car damage!

      I would also say an impending gearbox failure is much less serious than a brake failure.
      A broken gearbox stops you finishing, brake failure sends you into the barriers as we saw.

      I think I read somewhere that Force India checked with the stewards to see if they could warn their drivers about the brake issue and were told no - did Mercedes check first before they alerted Nico?

      • + 0
      • Jul 11 2016 - 20:33

BE Grand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

BEGrand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

World Championship standings 2024

Show full world champion standings

Test calendar

See full test schedule

Related news

Give your opinion!

Will Bottas challenge Hamilton for the world championship in 2020?

Formula 1 Calendar - 2024

Date
Grand Prix
Circuit
-
Bahrain
29 - Mar 2
Bahrain
7 - Mar 9
Saudi Arabia
22 - Mar 24
Australia
5 - Apr 7
Japan
19 - Apr 21
China
3 - May 5
United States of America
17 - May 19
Italy
24 - May 26
Monaco
7 - Jun 9
Canada
21 - Jun 23
Spain
28 - Jun 30
Austria
5 - Jul 7
United Kingdom
19 - Jul 21
Hungary
26 - Jul 28
Belgium
23 - Aug 25
Netherlands
30 - Sep 1
Italy
13 - Sep 15
Azerbaijan
20 - Sep 22
Singapore
18 - Oct 20
United States of America
25 - Oct 27
Mexico
1 - Nov 3
Brazil
22 - Nov 24
United States of America
29 - Dec 1
Qatar
6 - Dec 8
United Arab Emirates
See full schedule

Formula 1 Calendar - 2024

Date
Grand Prix & Circuit
29 - Mar 2
7 - Mar 9
Saudi Arabia Jeddah Street Circuit
22 - Mar 24
Australia Albert Park
5 - Apr 7
19 - Apr 21
3 - May 5
United States of America Miami International Autodrome
17 - May 19
24 - May 26
Monaco Monte Carlo
7 - Jun 9
21 - Jun 23
28 - Jun 30
Austria Red Bull Ring
5 - Jul 7
United Kingdom Silverstone
19 - Jul 21
Hungary Hungaroring
26 - Jul 28
23 - Aug 25
Netherlands Circuit Zandvoort
30 - Sep 1
Italy Monza
13 - Sep 15
Azerbaijan Baku City Circuit
20 - Sep 22
18 - Oct 20
United States of America Circuit of the Americas
25 - Oct 27
1 - Nov 3
Brazil Interlagos
22 - Nov 24
United States of America Las Vegas Street Circuit
29 - Dec 1
6 - Dec 8
United Arab Emirates Yas Marina Circuit
See full schedule

Driver profile

  • Team Red Bull Racing
  • Points 2,980
  • Podiums 111
  • Grand Prix 206
  • Country NL
  • Date of b. Sep 30 1997 (27)
  • Place of b. Hasselt (Belgie), NL
  • Weight 70 kg
  • Length 1.8 m
Show full profile

Team profile

Show full profile
show sidebar